Last updated on .
How the Creative Fatigue Score works
Creative fatigue is what happens when the same people see the same ad too many times and stop noticing it. Click-through rates can fall by up to 50% once it sets in. It shows up in frequency and click-through rate about a fortnight before it shows up in cost per acquisition. The Creative Fatigue Score (CFS) puts those two early signals into one number:
CFS = (Frequency ÷ 2.5) × (Peak CTR ÷ Current CTR)
| Input | What it is |
|---|---|
| Frequency | The average number of times each person has seen the ad over the last 7 to 14 days. |
| 2.5 | The frequency where decline typically begins. Change it in the calculator if your own account data shows a different threshold. |
| Peak CTR | The ad's best three-day click-through rate. |
| Current CTR | The ad's click-through rate now. A peak-to-current ratio of 1.0 means it is still at its peak; 2.0 means CTR has halved. |
Each number is noisy on its own. A high frequency can be fine if CTR is holding, and a CTR dip can be a quiet week. Multiplying them separates real fatigue from noise. The full reasoning is in our article on how to measure creative fatigue.
How to read your score
| Score | Status | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Below 1.2 | Healthy | The ad is carrying its weight. Leave it alone. |
| 1.2 to 1.5 | Watch | Fatigue is starting. Get the replacement into production now. |
| Above 1.5 | Fatigued | Replace it. Don't iterate on it or nudge the budget. Retire it and promote the next creative in the queue. |
A worked example
A mid-funnel video has been running for three weeks. Its frequency over the last fortnight is 3.1. Its best three-day CTR was 1.8% and it is now running at 1.0%.
CFS = (3.1 ÷ 2.5) × (1.8 ÷ 1.0) = 1.24 × 1.8 = 2.23
That is well above 1.5. The cost per acquisition may still look acceptable today, but the audience has moved on and the cost rise is on its way. Replace it this week. This is the first example loaded in the calculator above.
Where to find the numbers in Ads Manager
- Open the Ads tab and set the date range to the last 7 or 14 days.
- Add the Frequency and CTR columns. Those give you frequency and current CTR for each ad.
- For peak CTR, widen the date range to the ad's whole run, break the results down by day, and take the best three consecutive days.
- Enter one row per ad. The calculator sorts them from most to least fatigued.
Why 2.5, and when to change it
2.5 is a starting benchmark. Fatigue onset depends on audience size, how many distinct creatives are in rotation and your category. A broad audience with ten different ads tolerates a higher frequency than a narrow retargeting pool shown one video. The direction of travel is towards shorter cycles: refreshing every three to four weeks used to be defensible, and accounts that refresh every two weeks now hold a clear CTR advantage over those refreshing monthly. Tighten your threshold over time, and treat a rise in account-level frequency as a prompt to score individual ads.
What to do with the list
Everything above 1.5 goes on the replacement list today. Everything between 1.2 and 1.5 goes into production this week. If that leaves you scrambling for one new ad at a time, the fix is a production cadence that puts fresh creative into the account before the current batch tips over. The Creative Volume Calculator turns your budget into the number of ads that cadence needs, and our creative production team builds to it in two-week sprints.
A healthy score with poor results means the problem is not fatigue. It may be a message that doesn't match the audience, or every ad in the account looking the same. We cover how to tell them apart in why your ad creative is failing.